Published by Eerdmans on April 14, 2026
Genres: Non-Fiction, Christian Life
Buy on Amazon
Goodreads
Normal is a myth―and recognizing that truth can free us all.
In a world obsessed with fitting in, Better Than Normal dares to ask a revolutionary question: What if the problem isn’t people who don’t conform, but the idea of “normal” itself?
Author and pastor MaryAnn McKibben Dana delivers a powerful critique of society’s restrictive expectations while offering a transformative vision for human flourishing. Drawing from her experience as a mother navigating mental health challenges with her children, she reveals how forcing people into ill-fitting boxes creates cycles of shame, stigma, and othering that diminish us all.
This isn’t just another self-help book―it’s an exploration of how culture shapes our understanding of worthiness and belonging. And it’s a study that extends far beyond mental health to encompass anyone living outside society’s narrow bounds―neurodivergent individuals, LGBTQ+ people, racial minorities, those with disabilities―populations that collectively represent the majority of us. McKibben Dana demonstrates that liberation comes not from adjusting to dominant culture, but from creating spaces where all people can thrive authentically.
Normal is a myth. The central thesis of MaryAnn McKibben Dana’s Better than Normal is both whispered and shouted on every page. Whispered for those moments when you need quiet exhortation to perseverance. Shouted for those moments when you need someone in your corner protecting you. Dana lays down the deeply prophetic truth that what’s normal probably isn’t what’s best and offers readers a life-giving liberating vision for what she calls an “off-script life.”
Better than Normal is divided into two parts: individual values and communal values. Each of these parts has three chapters dedicated to the movement from something normal to something a bit more abnormal—dangerous and discomforting but altogether more life-giving and loving. One of the first things that Dana does is call readers to curiosity. We, naturally I think, tend to crave certainty. And in that certainty we narrow our boundaries of normalcy. What is the default or majority of culture because what we see as normal and therefore anything outside of that is abnormal and disconcerting—a threat to our way of life.
You can see how a lot of conservative thinking revolves around this comforting desire for certainty and normalcy. Better than Normal asks us to explore with curiosity beyond our boundaries and see what God has in store for us. She stresses that we should lean into discomfort because it can change us for good, that we should want to move beyond the narrow confines of safety and grow up into a mature curiosity of the world.
It’s this foundational point that drives the rest of the book as Dana works with us to explore what it would mean to move from comfort to courage, productivity to presence, artifice to authenticity, blandness to beauty, and competition to community. In each of these movements, Better than Normal challenges the default setting that most of us in majority culture are on and calls us to a better, freer, more inclusive journey in life.
Throughout the book, Dana shares her own story, being a perfect example of authenticity. She writes of her own family’s struggles and how their pivot out of normalcy wasn’t a nicely planned choice but a sucker punch of family trauma and difficulty. That perspective helps because I know that a lot of folks who have moved from their normal into a period of discombobulation often want nothing else other than to get back to normal. That was the hope of the whole world during COVID, right? To return to normalcy? Never mind that what COVID unveiled was that normal wasn’t working for a lot of people. Rather, Dana shows her family found freedom and healing in the non-normalcy of life.
Better than Normal is a short, powerful book full of lived, practical, pastoral wisdom. When you live off-script, every journey looks different, but Dana offers readers a broad guide toward leaving the constraints of expectation and into the freedom and flourishing that being non-normal can bring.