Goodreads
Over twenty years after the Oscar-lauded films, fifty years since the death of the books’ author, and seventy years since its publication, JRR Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings still commands significant interest. People continue to be interested in the land of Middle-Earth, in Tolkien’s complex fantasy languages, in the themes and characters and places he created. There are whole university level courses and degrees in Tolkien. I know people who have gotten doctorates through studying Middle-Earth.
Sometimes, though, you just want to dip a toe in deep, deep waters. Maybe you’ve read the books once—or maybe just listened to Andy Serkis’ fantastic audio version or just watched the Peter Jackson films—but you know there’s more to this world and it’s just so overwhelming where you might begin. Enter Facts of the Fellowship: 99 Obscure Lord of the Rings Facts from Tolkien’s Middle-Earth. Tolkien nerd Don Marshall (sometimes known as The Obscure Lord of the Rings Facts Guy, an unwieldly if accurate nickname) gives casual fans an accessible entry point into the deeper lore of Lord of the Rings.
I will say that calling it “99 Obscure Facts” is a little bit of a misnomer. Marshall covers 99 different topics—people, places, and events—in a mini-encyclopedia style, offering 2-3 pages for each entry. I wish I knew exactly how Marshall and the publisher decided on the order of the entries, though, because it’s not topical or alphabetical. It seems to sort of loosely follow Middle-Earth’s chronology, but even that isn’t quite it. It’s an odd choice to be disorganized inside when the whole look and feel of the book showcases the opposite.
And then, within the entries, I don’t know that Marshall always does a great job of staying on topic. For example, the first entry is about Eru Iluvatar, the god figure within Tolkien’s legendarium. Marshall devotes four paragraphs to talking about Eru. The first says he is the god of the legendarium. The second very quickly details the creation of the Ainur and how, together, they created Ea—the created universe. The third and fourth move off-topic to talk about Arda (earth) and the Ainur. There is an inset paragraph that goes a bit deeper, quoting a letter of Tolkien about how the elves don’t worship Eru as a god—presumably this is the obscure fact—but it overlooks that the Numenorians did and held worship of any other deity to be an abomination.
Other entries vary in their substance, but the length and style end up meaning that Marshall ends up saying a lot without saying much at all. Folks who really want to dive into Tolkien lore would be better served by Tolkien Gateway, a free wiki, that covers everything that Facts of the Fellowship does in a more organized, more substantive, more cohesive way.
I will say that Facts of the Fellowship is a beautifully made book. It looks good on a bookshelf and that may have been the primary hope of the publisher. Tolkien book collecting is big and the Tolkien Estate and other have tried in a myriad of ways of capitalize on anything and everything Tolkien related. This might be good for the casual fan who has watched the films and not much else. It’s a good companion to Marshall’s much better JRR Tolkien: The Father of Modern Fantasy.